Choose the correct alternative from the clues given at the end of each statement: (a) The size of the atom in Thomson's model is .......... the atomic size in Rutherford's model. (b) In the ground state of .......... electrons are in stable equilibrium, while in .......... electrons always experience a net force. (c) A classical atom based on .......... is doomed to collapse. (d) An atom has a nearly continuous mass distribution in a .......... but has a highly non-uniform mass distribution in .......... (e) The positively charged part of the atom possesses most of the mass in ..........
Hint. Contrast the two models on where the positive charge sits and whether the electron is at rest or in orbit.
(a) no different from. Both models describe an atom of roughly m. What differs is the arrangement of charge inside, not the overall size.
(b) Thomson's model; Rutherford's model. In Thomson's model the electrons sit embedded in a uniform sphere of positive charge, where the net force on them is zero, so they are in stable equilibrium. In Rutherford's model the electron orbits the nucleus and is always being pulled towards it, so it always experiences a net force.
(c) Rutherford's model. An orbiting electron is accelerating, and classical electromagnetism requires an accelerating charge to radiate energy continuously. Losing energy, it would spiral inward and reach the nucleus in about s, so the classical Rutherford atom is unstable.
(d) Thomson's model; Rutherford's model. Thomson spread the positive charge and mass smoothly through the whole atom. Rutherford concentrated almost all of it into a nucleus about m across, leaving the rest of the atom essentially empty.
(e) both the models. In each case the positive part carries nearly all the mass, since electrons are around 1836 times lighter than a proton. The models differ in how that positive matter is distributed, not in how much mass it carries.
✦ (a) no different from (b) Thomson's model; Rutherford's model (c) Rutherford's model (d) Thomson's model; Rutherford's model (e) both the models
